Rubric

Find Rubric
Keep in mind that 52 students have already been assessed using this rubric. Changing it will affect their evaluations.
At the Movies Essay Rubric
At the Movies Essay Rubric
Criteria Ratings Pts
Film Synopsis
Synopsis of the film; describe and analyze the fraud/crime committed in the movie
threshold: pts
10 pts
Excellent
Concise, brief synopsis of the film, characters, and fraud theme. One page or less
8 pts
Most elements present
6 pts
Some elements present
4 pts
Few elements present
pts
10 pts
--
Exploration of Fraud Theories
Application of the Fraud Triangle and other fraud theories to the characters of the film
threshold: pts
15 pts
Excellent
Fraud Triangle and at least one other fraud theory are effectively applied and discussed.
12 pts
Most elements present
9 pts
Some elements present
6 pts
Few elements present
pts
15 pts
--
White-Collar Crime Theme
Identify and describe the primary fraud theme of the film
threshold: pts
5 pts
Excellent
Effectively identify and describe the primary fraud theme of the film
4 pts
Most elements present
3 pts
Some elements present
2 pts
Few elements present
pts
5 pts
--
Protagonist
Description of the protagonist(s) and the dilemma he/she/they faced. Discussion of the personality, conduct, and motivations of the perpetrator(s).
threshold: pts
15 pts
Excellent
Effectively describe the protagonist(s) and the dilemma he/she/they faced, including relating this effectively to fraud theories discussed. Detailed discussion of the personality, conduct, and motivations of the perpetrator(s).
12 pts
Most elements present
9 pts
Some elements present
6 pts
Few elements present
pts
15 pts
--
The Crime
Identification and description of the criminal offenses and applicable laws.
threshold: pts
10 pts
Excellent
Effective identification and description of the criminal offenses and applicable laws.
8 pts
Most elements present
6 pts
Some elements present
4 pts
Few elements present
pts
10 pts
--
The Victims
Identification and description of various victims of the crime(s) and the damages and losses suffered.
threshold: pts
10 pts
Excellent
Effective, detailed identification and description of various victims of the crime(s) and the damages and losses suffered.
8 pts
Most elements present
6 pts
Some elements present
4 pts
Few elements present
pts
10 pts
--
The Outcome
A detailed discussion of how the offense was prosecuted, defended, or adjudicated or how it might have been.
threshold: pts
15 pts
Excellent
Detailed, effective discussion of how the offense was prosecuted, defended, or adjudicated or how it might have been.
12 pts
Most elements present
9 pts
Some elements present
6 pts
Few elements present
pts
15 pts
--
Writing
The essay is written concisely and clearly, organized well, with few errors.
threshold: pts
10 pts
Excellent
The essay is written concisely and clearly, organized well, with few errors.
8 pts
Most elements present
6 pts
Some elements present
4 pts
Few elements present
pts
10 pts
--
Other Analysis
Did the author consider any of the following:
- Victimization and victim psychology
- Moral ambiguity and societal response
- Immoral and/or illegal conduct
- Sufficiency of enforcement/punishment
- Other observations or responses
threshold: pts
10 pts
Excellent
The author effectively discussed and analyzed two or more of the other analysis elements
8 pts
Most elements present
6 pts
Some elements present
4 pts
Few elements present
pts
10 pts
--
Total Points: 100 out of 100