3B: Formative vs. Summative Assessment
Many instructors think of assessments as an endpoint, where students show what they have learned (past tense). Chances are that most of the assessments you wrote down in the previous exercise are these types of "endpoint" activities, also called summative assessments. Summative assessments are things like homework assignments, exams, papers or projects; they are typically high-stakes, often resulting in a final grade that is supposed to reflect whether students have learned something.
However, assessments can instead be an important part of the learning process itself. Formative assessments are typically low-stakes activities designed primarily to provide information on whether and how students are learning in order to inform instructor and student behavior.
Video on formative assessment
Links to an external site.
How will you track student progress?
Recall that one of the components of inclusive teaching is being proactive. But in order to be proactive about reaching out to students who need support, you need to know they need support! Formative assessments allow us to see how students are progressing - allowing us, as instructors, to make changes or help as needed - before they reach the summative assessments that measure whether they've reached the goal.
To start thinking about how to use formative assessments, it can be useful to go back to your list of outcomes and the evidence you want students to produce, then try to identify the specific knowledge and skills that students will need in order to be able to produce that evidence successfully. Note that if you did the scaffolding exercise in the previous module to create learning outcomes for individual units or weeks, you may have already incorporated much of this information into those intermediate outcomes.
Identifying Formative Assessments
Use this assessment worksheet Download assessment worksheet to create a list of your summative assessments, then try to identify the specific knowledge and skills that students will need in order to succeed on that assessment. In the next module, we will consider the activities that will help students acquire the requisite knowledge and skills but can you think of formative assessments that will help you monitor whether students are on track along the way?
For example: Going back to the introductory Economics course, with a CLO to "analyze the impact of government policies on different types of markets" that is assessed by having students provide a correct analysis of government policies on different types of markets, we can the break down the specific knowledge/skills/attitudes they need in order to produce that evidence as understanding of concepts like elasticity, equilibrium, supply and demand, etc. and practice manipulating graphs. One common formative assessment to check understanding is a quiz to be completed before coming to class (or moving on within a module in an online course), or clicker questions asked during a lecture.